Product Reviews

Overall rating

2 / 5

Quality

4 / 5

Comfort

2 / 5

Style

4 / 5

1 size too small

1 size too big

Too narrow

Too wide

Channy

Fitness needs/level:Light Daily Activity

Shoe expertise:I shop for shoes when I need something specific.

Gender:Female

Where are the narrow choices when you need them >

PostedApril 22, 2014

Prosdurable, versatile, stylish

Consdifficult to walk in, uncomfortable, not in narrow widths ..i'm a 9.5-10aa

I mainly get irritated that so many shoes do not come in narrow widths or will only do it for 3 0r so sizes...Come on......all my life this has been true...but Naturalizer used to be different. I liked the look of the shoe but because I had to order a medium width...which is OK for a tennis shoe....it did not fit...so I have to send it back....I'd only recommend to friend with a non-narrow foot.

1 of 1 found this review helpful.

Overall rating

5 / 5

Quality

5 / 5

Comfort

5 / 5

Style

5 / 5

1 size too small

1 size too big

Too narrow

Too wide

Jacqlyn

Shoe expertise:I enjoy shopping for shoes and update my footwear each season.

Age:35-44

Gender:Female

Great Shoes

PostedApril 16, 2014

Prosversatile, stylish, cushioning

I have a very narrow foot and have more difficulty finding trendy, cool shoes. Saw these online. I bought 5 other pair and kept them all. I needed new shoes for a trip to Mexico. They were perfect! Very versatile and went from casual to evening. Extremely comfortable as well. I would buy them in more colors if I did not already have another 5 pair of Naturalizers!

Overall rating

5 / 5

Quality

5 / 5

Comfort

5 / 5

Style

5 / 5

1 size too small

1 size too big

Too narrow

Too wide

dls74447

fromTN

Fitness needs/level:Exercise Regularly

Shoe expertise:I shop for shoes when I need something specific.

Age:65-74

Gender:Female

Best of all I bought

PostedApril 5, 2014

Proscomfortable, versatile, stylish, cushioning

Consuncomfortable, crved seam is painful in most i bought except 2.

Online the style is pretty. At home just gorgeous! Classy, Rich looking. Impressive.
First I must mention I bought one of each color in this style. Liked them that much! TILL! On first I'd not noticed the irritating seam at ball of foot on my red pair. When I got the last- the Ivory pair. (All from other companies than Naturalizer.com) I could not even step on ball of foot. The seam stuck me in the ball of foot at the most tender spot under toes near ball. Especially if I took a step let alone the pain standing in them it caused. So had no choice but to go relook & return all colors. Oh so sad. Beautiful shoe!!! & colors wonderfully done. Returned all...regretfully as I loved the style & comfort was perfect EXCEPT this rediculous seam.
Good news is...Day I returned the last shoe I recieved in mail two more. The Patina & Metal Alloy Carlita.
I'd forgot I'd only been able to find these colors on Naturalizer site. Almost sent them back w/o trying on. But I know how different each shoe can be. Yeah even Naturalizers.
OK, tried on, confused but very happy. I get to keep at least these two! Yea! For some reason these two's curved seams NO NOT hit my feet like all the others did. I don't have old one to compare, but it looks to me like these two have the seam just a hair enough "further up" to not hurt my feet like the ones I returned did. So keeping them.
Each shoe I returned was more or less irritating at the seam. Each a little better or worse but still would have made ball of my feet sore.
These Carlitas if you don't consider the badly placed HIGH stitched seam edge on the others I bought & returned, are perfect & beautiful! All Fit my 8.5W foot just right & were so comfortable in general. good padding. These two had a better seam & worked.
I was extremely relieved to keep two so pretty. Hope wearing them out will prove me right. Could just have been my foot but still wondering why these two -only-worked. New batch. Different maker? Buying directly from Naturalizer?
Love Naturalizers btw.
Give these a try. Could just be MY feet. Still a well made, beautiful shoe that needs redesigned for me.
P.S. If I could get the red to fit like Metal Alloy & Patina at that seam, I'd buy it today.

Overall rating