I know it has been a while since I have ordered shoes, but I swear they must have changed their sizing. Unfortunatly these shoes and the other shoes I ordered were both too large. And since I wear a narrow shoe I doubt I will be ordering any time soon, since they don't make 6 1/2 in Narrow. Sadly disappointed, especially when this was one of the few companies I could order from.
I have last year's model of this same shoe that I like very much. I thought the body of this shoe would be a more yellow/golden color .. and that I would have two of the same style shoe in different colors. But, in fact, this shoe is a chestnut brown -- the exact same color as my other pair. Since I ordered them online it was too much of a hassle to bring them back (the closest Naturalizer store is 40+ miles away) and not worth the cost to ship them back.
I actually returned mine, because I didn't feel like they were all that comfortable. The button-like detail is cute, and the shoes are good quality. My feet are sort of wide, which probably played into the situation (even though I did get a wide).